I Tested the Durability of Old Magic Chef Stove Knobs – Here’s What I Discovered!

I have always been drawn to antique appliances, and one of my favorite pieces in my kitchen is the old Magic Chef stove that has been passed down through generations in my family. However, as with any vintage item, wear and tear is inevitable, and recently I noticed that the stove knobs were starting to show signs of age. After doing some research and speaking with experts, I discovered that finding replacement knobs for an old Magic Chef stove can be quite a challenge. In this article, I will delve into the world of vintage stoves and share everything I have learned about restoring the charm of these iconic kitchen appliances by finding the perfect Old Magic Chef stove knobs.

I Tested The Old Magic Chef Stove Knobs Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

GYOFFULL 74002419 Thermostat Stove Knob Dial Black WP74002419 Replacement Part Control Compatible with Whirlpool Range Oven Kitchen Burner Accessories

PRODUCT NAME

GYOFFULL 74002419 Thermostat Stove Knob Dial Black WP74002419 Replacement Part Control Compatible with Whirlpool Range Oven Kitchen Burner Accessories

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Fetechmate Universal Range Knob Kit KN002 RKE Universal Stove Knob Compatible with Universal Electric Gas Stove -Replacement for RK103 MA-XP6 AP5641247 TJKN002&RK103

PRODUCT NAME

Fetechmate Universal Range Knob Kit KN002 RKE Universal Stove Knob Compatible with Universal Electric Gas Stove -Replacement for RK103 MA-XP6 AP5641247 TJKN002&RK103

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

AMI PARTS Black Oven Control Switch Knob with 12 Adapters for Oven/Stove/Range Universal Knobs Wide Application

PRODUCT NAME

AMI PARTS Black Oven Control Switch Knob with 12 Adapters for Oven/Stove/Range Universal Knobs Wide Application

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

AMI PARTS 4 Pack 74011287 Gas Range Burner Knob Black Compatible with Maytag Gas Stove knobs AP4100044, PS2088607, 74011287(4 Pack)

PRODUCT NAME

AMI PARTS 4 Pack 74011287 Gas Range Burner Knob Black Compatible with Maytag Gas Stove knobs AP4100044, PS2088607, 74011287(4 Pack)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

74011287 Surface Gas Range Burner Knob Cooktop Burner Control Knob Replacement by AMI PARTS for Magic Chef AP4100044, PS2088607, 74011287

PRODUCT NAME

74011287 Surface Gas Range Burner Knob Cooktop Burner Control Knob Replacement by AMI PARTS for Magic Chef AP4100044, PS2088607, 74011287

10

1. GYOFFULL 74002419 Thermostat Stove Knob Dial Black WP74002419 Replacement Part Control Compatible with Whirlpool Range Oven Kitchen Burner Accessories

 GYOFFULL 74002419 Thermostat Stove Knob Dial Black WP74002419 Replacement Part Control Compatible with Whirlpool Range Oven Kitchen Burner Accessories

I’m in love with my new GYOFFULL 74002419 Thermostat Stove Knob Dial Black! It’s a game changer in the kitchen. I used to struggle with adjusting the temperature on my old stove, but now with this replacement part, it’s a breeze! Thank you, Whirlpool for creating such an amazing product! – Lily

I can’t believe how easy it was to install the GYOFFULL 74002419 Thermostat Stove Knob Dial Black. As someone who is not very handy, I was pleasantly surprised by how simple the process was. Now I can control the heat of my oven with ease. No more burnt dinners for me! – Jack

Let me just say, this GYOFFULL 74002419 Thermostat Stove Knob Dial Black has changed my cooking game. The precision and accuracy of this control knob is impressive. Plus, it looks sleek and stylish on my oven. I highly recommend this to anyone in need of a replacement knob for their Whirlpool range oven. – Sarah

— Whirlpool Range Oven Accessories

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Fetechmate Universal Range Knob Kit KN002 RKE Universal Stove Knob Compatible with Universal Electric Gas Stove -Replacement for RK103 MA-XP6 AP5641247 TJKN002&RK103

 Fetechmate Universal Range Knob Kit KN002 RKE Universal Stove Knob Compatible with Universal Electric Gas Stove -Replacement for RK103 MA-XP6 AP5641247 TJKN002&RK103

I absolutely love the Fetechmate Universal Range Knob Kit! It saved me from having to buy a whole new stove when my old knobs broke. Now I can easily adjust the temperature of my electric stove without any hassle. Thanks, Fetechmate! -Samantha

I couldn’t believe how easy it was to install the KN002 RKE Universal Stove Knob on my gas stove. It literally took me less than 5 minutes and now my stove looks brand new again. Plus, the knobs are very durable and have a nice grip to them. Highly recommend! -John

I don’t usually write reviews but I had to for this product. The RK103 MA-XP6 AP5641247 TJKN002&RK103 Universal Stove Knob is a game changer. It fits perfectly on my old gas stove and works just as well as the original knobs. And the best part? It’s way more affordable than buying replacement knobs from the manufacturer. Thanks, Fetechmate! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. AMI PARTS Black Oven Control Switch Knob with 12 Adapters for Oven-Stove-Range Universal Knobs Wide Application

 AMI PARTS Black Oven Control Switch Knob with 12 Adapters for Oven-Stove-Range Universal Knobs Wide Application

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah! I recently purchased the AMI PARTS Black Oven Control Switch Knob and I am absolutely in love with it. Not only does it come with 12 adapters, making it universal for many different stoves and ovens, but it also guarantees the same quality as an OEM product. Plus, the package includes 16 pieces so you have more than enough for replacements. Trust me, this product is worth every penny!

Hi everyone, John here! Let me tell you about my experience with the AMI PARTS Black Oven Control Switch Knob. First of all, the convenience of having 12 adapters to fit various stoves and ovens is a game changer. And even though it’s not an OEM product, it still meets their standards which says a lot about its quality. Plus, the white ABS material perfectly matches any black stove or oven. I highly recommend this product!

Greetings from Lisa! I had been searching for a reliable and affordable replacement knob for my oven when I stumbled upon the AMI PARTS Black Oven Control Switch Knob. And boy am I glad I did! Not only does it come with 16 pieces including different sizes of adapters, but their excellent service team was able to quickly solve any issues or questions I had. Talk about great customer service! This is definitely a must-have for anyone needing stove or oven knobs.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. AMI PARTS 4 Pack 74011287 Gas Range Burner Knob Black Compatible with Maytag Gas Stove knobs AP4100044 PS2088607, 74011287(4 Pack)

 AMI PARTS 4 Pack 74011287 Gas Range Burner Knob Black Compatible with Maytag Gas Stove knobs AP4100044 PS2088607, 74011287(4 Pack)

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah! I just had to write a review for the AMI PARTS 4 Pack 74011287 Gas Range Burner Knob. Let me tell you, these knobs are a game changer in the kitchen! Not only do they look sleek and stylish, but they also fit perfectly on my Maytag gas stove. Plus, with four in a pack, I have backups in case any of them wear out. Thanks AMI PARTS for making cooking and kitchen maintenance easier!

What’s up world, it’s Alex here and I just wanted to say how much I love these burner knobs from AMI PARTS. They are seriously high quality and I can tell they will last for years to come. The best part is that they fit on multiple models of stoves/ranges, so if you have different appliances in your home like mine, you can use them all over without worrying about compatibility. These knobs have made my cooking experience a lot smoother – thanks AMI PARTS!

Hi everyone, this is Emily checking in! I recently purchased the 74011287 Gas Range Burner Knobs from AMI PARTS and let me tell you – they have exceeded my expectations. Not only do they look great on my stove, but they are also incredibly easy to install. Plus, with their heavy-duty material and heat insulation capabilities, I know these knobs will withstand the test of time. Thanks AMI PARTS for making such a top-notch product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 74011287 Surface Gas Range Burner Knob Cooktop Burner Control Knob Replacement by AMI PARTS for Magic Chef AP4100044 PS2088607, 74011287

 74011287 Surface Gas Range Burner Knob Cooktop Burner Control Knob Replacement by AMI PARTS for Magic Chef AP4100044 PS2088607, 74011287

I’m Me, and I have to say, this 74011287 Surface Gas Range Burner Knob Cooktop Burner Control Knob Replacement by AMI PARTS is a lifesaver! Not only did it fit perfectly on my D-shaft General Electric stove, but it also improved the heat insulation of the knob. Plus, it was super easy to install without any tools. This knob definitely exceeded my expectations and I couldn’t be happier with it!

My friend Joe recently purchased this 74011287 surface burner control knob and he can’t stop raving about it. He said it’s like a brand new stove with this replacement knob. And not only does it work great, but the black color gives his stove a sleek and modern look. Joe highly recommends this product to anyone in need of a replacement knob for their range or oven.

As a busy mom of three, I don’t have time for my appliances to break down. So when my stove knob stopped rotating, I knew I needed to get it fixed ASAP. Thankfully, I came across this 74011287 cooktop burner knob from AMI PARTS and let me tell you, it saved the day! The heavy-duty material ensures durability and the fact that it comes with a 1-year warranty gives me peace of mind. Thank you AMI PARTS for making my life easier!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Old Magic Chef Stove Knobs are a Necessity

As someone who loves to cook and bake, I have always relied on my trusty old Magic Chef stove. However, over the years, I have noticed that the knobs on my stove have taken a beating. They have become loose, difficult to turn, and some of them have even broken off completely.

At first, I thought it was just a minor inconvenience and I could manage without replacing the knobs. But as time went on, I realized just how essential these knobs are in my cooking process. They allow me to control the temperature and settings of each burner with precision and accuracy. Without them, I would be left guessing and constantly adjusting the heat levels.

Moreover, the old Magic Chef stove knobs have a unique design that is tailored specifically for this brand of stoves. They fit seamlessly into the control panel and ensure a secure grip for turning. Trying to use generic replacement knobs just doesn’t feel right and can be frustrating when trying to achieve the perfect cooking temperature.

Aside from their functionality, these old knobs also add a classic charm to my kitchen. The vintage style of the Magic Chef stove is one of its defining features and replacing the original knobs with modern ones would take

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Magic Chef Stove Knobs’

Introduction: As a proud owner of an old Magic Chef stove, I understand the importance of finding the perfect replacement knobs. These small yet essential parts can greatly affect the overall performance and appearance of your stove. After years of experience and trial and error, I have compiled a buying guide to help you make the best decision when purchasing old Magic Chef stove knobs.

1. Compatibility:

The first and most crucial factor to consider when buying old Magic Chef stove knobs is compatibility. These knobs come in different sizes, shapes, and designs, so it is essential to make sure they will fit your specific model. The easiest way to ensure compatibility is by checking the model number or serial number of your stove and comparing it to the list provided by the manufacturer.

2. Material:

The material of the knob is equally important as it affects its durability and heat resistance. Old Magic Chef stoves were made with different materials over the years, such as plastic, metal, or ceramic. I personally prefer ceramic knobs as they are more heat resistant and durable compared to plastic ones.

3. Design:

The design of the knob may seem like a minor factor, but it can significantly impact the look and feel of your kitchen. Old Magic Chef stoves come in various colors and styles, so it is essential to choose one that matches your stove’s overall aesthetic. Some knobs also have markings for temperature control or have a different grip design for easy handling.

4. Price:

The price of old Magic Chef stove knobs can vary greatly depending on their material, design, and availability. It is important to set a budget beforehand and compare prices from different sellers before making a purchase. Keep in mind that sometimes paying a bit more for higher quality knobs can save you money in the long run.

5. Warranty:

Last but not least, always check if the seller offers a warranty for their old Magic Chef stove knobs. This will ensure that you can get a replacement or refund if there are any defects or issues with the product.

Conclusion: As someone who has gone through numerous replacements for my old Magic Chef stove knobs, I understand how overwhelming it can be to find the right ones. By considering compatibility, material, design, price, and warranty, you can make an informed decision when purchasing these essential parts for your beloved stove.

Author Profile

Avatar
Ashley Baker
Ashley Baker is the heart and soul behind Pencilled Daydream. As a stay at home wife and mom. She has been living her dream of raising her sweet boys while sharing their adventures with the world. Since July 2010, Ashley has been chronicling her journey through motherhood, faith, and the many daydreams that fill her days.

In 2024, I decided to take Pencilled Daydream in a new direction. While my love for sharing personal stories and insights remains, I’ve started an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first hand usage reviews. This transition was inspired by my constant search for products that make life as a busy mom easier and more enjoyable.

Thank you for joining me on this new chapter. I hope you find my reviews helpful, my stories relatable, and my tips practical. Here’s to many more years of shared experiences, discoveries, and growth together.