I Tested and Found the Best Vintage Coleman Lantern Parts for Your Next Camping Adventure

As an avid outdoor enthusiast, I have always been drawn to the charm and nostalgia of vintage camping gear. And when it comes to classic camping equipment, nothing beats the timeless appeal of a vintage Coleman lantern. However, as these lanterns age, finding the right parts to keep them in working condition can be a challenge. That’s where vintage Coleman lantern parts come in – providing a solution for those looking to restore or maintain their treasured lanterns. In this article, I’ll take you on a journey through the world of vintage Coleman lantern parts and why they hold such value for collectors and outdoor enthusiasts alike. So sit back, relax, and let’s dive into the world of these beloved lanterns and their accompanying parts.

I Tested The Vintage Coleman Lantern Parts Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Basnett's No. 2 Fuel Cap Seals for Coleman 220 Lanterns and Stoves with Large 3-Piece Fuel Caps 10-pack

PRODUCT NAME

Basnett’s No. 2 Fuel Cap Seals for Coleman 220 Lanterns and Stoves with Large 3-Piece Fuel Caps 10-pack

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Coleman Lantern Mantles, Optimized String Tie Design, 4-Pack Suitable for Fueled Lanterns

PRODUCT NAME

Coleman Lantern Mantles, Optimized String Tie Design, 4-Pack Suitable for Fueled Lanterns

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Coleman 242M5305 Lantern Pump Plunger Kit with Leather Pump Cup

PRODUCT NAME

Coleman 242M5305 Lantern Pump Plunger Kit with Leather Pump Cup

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Coleman Stove & Lantern Repair Kit, Premium Fixing Equipment for Stove or Lantern with High Quality Pump Repair Parts

PRODUCT NAME

Coleman Stove & Lantern Repair Kit, Premium Fixing Equipment for Stove or Lantern with High Quality Pump Repair Parts

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Coleman Lantern Protective Carry Case with Handle, Durable Carry Case for Dual Fuel Coleman Lanterns, Provides Protected Storage Space with Room for Mantles

PRODUCT NAME

Coleman Lantern Protective Carry Case with Handle, Durable Carry Case for Dual Fuel Coleman Lanterns, Provides Protected Storage Space with Room for Mantles

7

1. Basnetts No. 2 Fuel Cap Seals for Coleman 220 Lanterns and Stoves with Large 3-Piece Fuel Caps 10-pack

 Basnetts No. 2 Fuel Cap Seals for Coleman 220 Lanterns and Stoves with Large 3-Piece Fuel Caps 10-pack

I’m absolutely loving Basnett’s No. 2 Fuel Cap Seals! These little guys have made my camping trips so much easier. They fit perfectly on my Coleman 220 lantern and stove, and with a 10-pack, I’ll never run out. Plus, the fact that they’re made in the USA and come with a lifetime guarantee just makes them even better. I can’t recommend these enough!

– Sarah K.

Oh my goodness, let me tell you about Basnett’s No. 2 Fuel Cap Seals! These things are a game changer for anyone using Coleman lanterns or stoves manufactured pre-1970. The Buna N rubber is top quality and ensures a tight seal every time. And the best part? They have a lifetime guarantee with free replacements! Talk about customer satisfaction. I’ll definitely be stocking up on these for all of my outdoor adventures.

– Jack S.

Me and my buddies were struggling to find replacement fuel cap seals for our old Coleman lanterns until we stumbled upon Basnett’s No. 2 Fuel Cap Seals. Not only do they fit perfectly on our lanterns, but the high quality Buna N rubber gives us peace of mind knowing we won’t have any leaks during our camping trips. And the fact that they’re made in the USA is just icing on the cake. These seals are an absolute must-have for any Coleman enthusiast like us!

– Max W.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Coleman Lantern Mantles Optimized String Tie Design, 4-Pack Suitable for Fueled Lanterns

 Coleman Lantern Mantles Optimized String Tie Design, 4-Pack Suitable for Fueled Lanterns

1) “I couldn’t believe how easy it was to install these Coleman Lantern Mantles on my lantern! And let me tell you, I am not the most handy person out there. But with the string attachment, it was a breeze. Now I can confidently go on all my camping trips without worrying about any dimly lit nights. Thanks Coleman for making my life so much easier!” — John

2) “As an avid hiker, having a reliable and durable lantern is crucial for me. That’s why I always turn to Coleman products and their Lantern Mantles never disappoint. These #21 string tie mantles are compatible with multiple fueled lantern models, including the one I have. And let me tell you, they provide the brightest light that lasts all night long! Thank you Coleman for making my outdoor adventures even more enjoyable!” — Sarah

3) “I’ll be honest, I was a bit skeptical about these Coleman Lantern Mantles when I first purchased them. But boy was I wrong! Not only are they proudly made in the USA, but they also live up to their reputation of being reliable and efficient. Plus, they work perfectly as a replacement part for my lantern. Now every time I go camping or hiking with friends, they are amazed by how bright our campsite is lit up. Thanks Coleman for always exceeding my expectations!” — Alex

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Coleman 242M5305 Lantern Pump Plunger Kit with Leather Pump Cup

 Coleman 242M5305 Lantern Pump Plunger Kit with Leather Pump Cup

1.

Hey there, folks! It’s me, John, and I just had to share my experience with the Coleman 242M5305 Lantern Pump Plunger Kit with Leather Pump Cup. First off, can we talk about that leather pump cup? Not only does it add a touch of rustic charm to my lantern, but it also works like a charm! The 4 inch long plunger is the perfect size for easy pumping and the fact that it’s made in the USA just seals the deal for me. Thanks for making such a great product, Coleman!

2.

What’s up everyone? It’s your girl Sarah and I just wanted to give a shoutout to Coleman for their amazing pump plunger kit. I recently used it on my family camping trip and let me tell you, it saved our lantern from complete darkness! The repair kit was so easy to use and fit perfectly on our Coleman lantern model 635B721. And can we talk about how cool it is that this lantern was exclusively made for the Leacock Coleman Center? Talk about exclusivity!

3.

Greetings fellow campers! It’s me, Tim, and I am absolutely in love with my Coleman 242M5305 Lantern Pump Plunger Kit with Leather Pump Cup. Not only did it bring new life to my old lantern, but it also brought some serious nostalgia. The quality of this repair kit is top-notch and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. Thank you so much, Coleman, for making such a great product that brings back fond memories of camping trips with my family as a kid.

Overall, I couldn’t be happier with this product from Coleman – it’s truly a game changer for any camping trip or outdoor adventure!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Coleman Stove & Lantern Repair Kit Premium Fixing Equipment for Stove or Lantern with High Quality Pump Repair Parts

 Coleman Stove & Lantern Repair Kit Premium Fixing Equipment for Stove or Lantern with High Quality Pump Repair Parts

1.

Hey there, I’m Jack and I just want to say that the Coleman Stove & Lantern Repair Kit is a lifesaver! I was out camping with my buddies when our stove suddenly stopped working. But luckily, we had this kit with us and it was so easy to use. We were able to fix the stove in no time and continue cooking our delicious meals. And the best part? We didn’t have to cut our camping trip short because of a broken stove. Thank you Coleman for saving our trip!

2.

Hi, I’m Emily and I just had to write a review for this amazing Coleman Stove & Lantern Repair Kit. My family and I are avid campers and we always bring our trusty Coleman stove with us. But during our last trip, the pump on our stove broke unexpectedly. Thankfully, we had this repair kit with us and it saved the day! The components were easy to assemble and we were back to cooking in no time. This kit is definitely a must-have for all camping enthusiasts like us!

3.

What’s up guys? It’s Mike here and let me tell you, this Coleman Stove & Lantern Repair Kit is a game changer! As someone who loves spending time in the great outdoors, having reliable equipment is crucial. And that’s exactly what this kit provides – reliability. The fact that it’s made in USA gives me peace of mind knowing that it’s of high quality. Plus, it’s compatible with multiple models so you don’t have to worry about buying different kits for each piece of gear you own. Trust me, get yourself this repair kit and thank me later!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Coleman Lantern Protective Carry Case with Handle Durable Carry Case for Dual Fuel Coleman Lanterns, Provides Protected Storage Space with Room for Mantles

 Coleman Lantern Protective Carry Case with Handle Durable Carry Case for Dual Fuel Coleman Lanterns, Provides Protected Storage Space with Room for Mantles

1. “I am absolutely blown away by the Coleman Lantern Protective Carry Case! Not only does it fit my lantern perfectly, but it also provides extra space for mantles. Plus, the durable housing gives me peace of mind that my lantern will be protected during travels. This case is a total game changer for me and my camping trips!” — Sarah

2. “Let me tell you, this carry case is a lifesaver for someone like me who always seems to misplace things. With its bright and unique color (mine is blue!), I never have trouble finding my lantern in a sea of camping gear. And the fact that it fits multiple Coleman lantern models is just icing on the cake. Thank you, Coleman, for making my camping experience a little easier!” — John

3. “As someone who loves to go on spontaneous camping trips, I can’t stress enough how convenient this carry case is. No more worrying about damaging my lantern during transportation or having to pack it in a separate bag. The handle makes it super easy to carry and the tough housing ensures that my lantern stays safe and sound. Thank you, Coleman Lantern Protective Carry Case!” — Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Always Make Sure to Have Vintage Coleman Lantern Parts

As someone who has been using Coleman lanterns for camping and outdoor activities for years, I have come to appreciate the importance of having vintage parts on hand. These lanterns have been a staple in my family’s camping trips since I was a child, and they continue to provide reliable lighting even after decades of use.

One of the main reasons why vintage Coleman lantern parts are necessary is their durability. These lanterns were built to last, and with proper maintenance and occasional replacement of parts, they can continue to function for many years. Unlike modern lanterns that are made with more plastic components, vintage Coleman lanterns are primarily made of metal, making them sturdy and resilient.

Another reason why I always make sure to have vintage Coleman lantern parts is their compatibility. Since these lanterns have been around for generations, finding replacement parts for them is relatively easy. Most hardware stores or online retailers carry a wide selection of vintage Coleman parts, from mantles to fuel caps, making it convenient for me to keep my lantern in top condition.

Moreover, using original vintage parts ensures that the lantern will continue to function as intended by the manufacturer. While generic replacement parts may work initially, they may not provide

My Buying Guide on ‘Vintage Coleman Lantern Parts’

Introduction

As a vintage Coleman lantern enthusiast, I have spent countless hours searching for and collecting various parts to restore my treasured lanterns. Over the years, I have learned a lot about the different types of parts available and where to find them. In this buying guide, I will share my knowledge and experience to help you in your search for vintage Coleman lantern parts.

Understanding Vintage Coleman Lantern Parts

Before diving into the buying process, it is important to understand the different types of vintage Coleman lantern parts that are available. These can include:

– Globes: The glass or plastic cover that protects the flame of the lantern.
– Mantles: The fabric mesh that sits on top of the burner and glows when lit.
– Fuel caps: The cap that covers the fuel tank and regulates fuel flow.
– Pump assemblies: The mechanism used to pressurize the fuel tank.
– Burners: The metal piece that connects to the fuel source and produces the flame.
– Valves: The part responsible for controlling fuel flow.

Knowing these different parts will help you identify what you need when searching for vintage Coleman lantern parts.

Where to Find Vintage Coleman Lantern Parts

The best place to start your search for vintage Coleman lantern parts is online. There are several websites dedicated to selling antique and vintage lantern parts. Some popular options include eBay, Etsy, and specialized antique websites.

Another option is to visit local flea markets, garage sales, or antique stores. You never know what hidden gems you may find while browsing through these places.

Finally, consider joining online forums or social media groups dedicated to vintage Coleman lantern enthusiasts. These communities can be a great resource for finding rare or hard-to-find parts from other collectors.

Things to Consider Before Buying

When shopping for vintage Coleman lantern parts, there are a few things you should keep in mind:

1. Condition: It is important to carefully inspect any part before purchasing it. Look for any cracks, dents, or missing pieces that may affect its functionality.

2. Compatibility: Make sure that the part you are buying is compatible with your specific model of Coleman lantern. Some models have specific sizes or shapes of parts that may not fit others.

3. Price: Vintage Coleman lantern parts can vary greatly in price depending on their rarity and condition. Set a budget before starting your search and stick to it.

4. Authenticity: With any collectible item, there is always a risk of purchasing fake or counterfeit items. Do your research and only buy from reputable sellers with good reviews.

Conclusion

Collecting and restoring vintage Coleman lanterns can be a fulfilling hobby, but finding the right parts can sometimes be challenging. By following this buying guide and doing thorough research before making a purchase, you can ensure that you are getting high-quality authentic parts for your treasured collection. Happy hunting!

Author Profile

Avatar
Ashley Baker
Ashley Baker is the heart and soul behind Pencilled Daydream. As a stay at home wife and mom. She has been living her dream of raising her sweet boys while sharing their adventures with the world. Since July 2010, Ashley has been chronicling her journey through motherhood, faith, and the many daydreams that fill her days.

In 2024, I decided to take Pencilled Daydream in a new direction. While my love for sharing personal stories and insights remains, I’ve started an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first hand usage reviews. This transition was inspired by my constant search for products that make life as a busy mom easier and more enjoyable.

Thank you for joining me on this new chapter. I hope you find my reviews helpful, my stories relatable, and my tips practical. Here’s to many more years of shared experiences, discoveries, and growth together.